Money or trophies? Probably both…

French playmaker Samir Nasri, has come out and said that footballers are already paid huge wages and that his next move is more about winning trophies, something he has failed to do in 6 years at senior level. Whilst I appreciate his sentiment in what is a clever move to show that he is not holding his club to ransom for a big payday, this is a bit of a smokescreen as one would know oh-so-well that he won’t be taking a pay cut to leave the Emirates. All being said I don’t think money is the reason Nasri is leaving the Emirates, and I don’t really think Arsenal fans can begrudge him the move.

I wouldn’t say Nasri is the finished article; he had a fantastic first half of last season, but like his employers lacked the punch at the business end of the season and faded away into nothing. But he is only 23 years of age and that is bound to come eventually. A look at his Arsenal teammate Cesc Fabregas shows how far a player can come on, given Fabregas’ starring role in an Arsenal side who were expected to suffer when the likes of Vieira and Henry had moved on. Gooners will say he is not quite the finished article and needs to give Arsenal and Wenger the loyalty they deserve as they can nurture him best. I agree with this in part. Staying at Arsenal under Wenger for another year or two would benefit the Frenchman, and develop him further, given that this is the first campaign in which he has shown the true quality that prompted his 15.6m signing form Marseille. However the timing doesn’t work for the Gunners. It’s best to sell their man now and recoup most, if not all, of the fee paid for him, and even make a profit, than lose him on a free next year.

And one would think Nasri signing a contract is unlikely due to his lack of interest in a big payday and moreso for trophies. And who can blame him? Arsenal haven’t won a trophy since the 2005 FA Cup, and a couple of League Cup Finals and the Champions League in 2006 haven’t really looked like they will anytime soon. The problem for the red half of North London seems to be the same every year. Pre-season predictions from ‘experts’ in the last few years, have always had Arsenal as the favourites to drop out of the ‘Top4’, yet they seem to surprise everyone by making a surprising rise to the summit. This normally implodes around February, most notably in the last few years in games against Birmingham, and the season kind of fizzles out from there. Meanwhile, young Nasri has to watch as Man United churn out title after title, Chelsea normally get in a couple of trophies every two years, and now Manchester City and their big-spending owners seem to have followed in Roman’s footsteps and begun their trophy haul. Meanwhile, Arsenal are still playing the prettiest football in the land, and its a shame they never win anything.

Funny enough, it is the three above-mentioned clubs that have all aired their interest in Nasri, and I think all of them qualify as having higher trophy aspirations than Arsenal. If he moved to Eastlands, it sounds like Nasri would be joined by French teammate Gael Clichy as his 7m move is expected to be finalised. Clichy will no doubt be used by the media to describe the ‘Emirates Exodus’ although in all truth I think many Arsenal fans will be glad to see the back of the defender who for all his rampaging runs forward and numerous assists, is prone to a mistake and has given away plenty of penalties in his 25 years. Still I think at 7m its good business for City who could do with a left back, and its good business for Arsenal, with Kieran Gibbs a like-for-like replacement waiting in the wings.

Whether City would be the number one choice for Nasri remains to be seen as the transfer seems a perfect fit for the current Champions. With Scholes retiring, United are calling out for an attacking midfielder with a bit of flair, and with Sneijder over-priced and Spurs unwilling to let Modric go, Samir is the best shout. It would be the best move for him too. He is a player who deserves to win trophies, and has put in a good, if what frustratingly inconsistent shift at Arsenal. But he has given the club some good years and will seemingly make a profit for them too.

And his departure will undoubtedly send warnings out for Arsenal fans who will also expect to see club captain Cesc Fabregas leave the club this summer for his boyhood side Barcelona. Moreso in Cesc’s case, Arsenal fans cannot begrudge the man who has given 8 yrs to the club, the chance to move to one of the biggest clubs in the world and undoubtedly win more trophies than he would of in North London.

The worrying time comes with what’s next. Jack Wilshere was superb last season, and Aaron Ramsey returned from injury well in the latter stages of the season. But they will have to replace one, if not both of their playmaking midfielders. But one has to be nervous about how the club do this given previous experience. Had Arsenal invested more in the past and offered better deals to players over the years to join the club, they may not have found themselves scrabbling around to offer Nasri a bumper deal in a desperate bid to keep him. Had they spent a bit more money they may have brought in the missing pieces of the puzzle which would mean players wanted to stay and the club might be more successful. Had they offered Mathieu Flamini a contract 4 years ago, they may have shored up the centre midfield position for the coming years. Had they invested in a world class centre back to strengthen the defence with Thomas Vermaelen, then Arsenal may not have leaked so many goals. Had they immediately searched for a world class goalkeeper the minute Jens Lehmann left the club, there may not have been so much chaos in the three years that followed. Had they looked for another top striker to bag 20+ goals a year once Henry was moved on, there may be more penetration in the Arsenal front line.

But instead there was a policy of youth and value. Arsenal waited for youth, and got lucky in the development of Alex Song to provide a defensive perspective to the midfield. They got lucky that Johan Djourou was in fine form last season, although his previous inconsistencies don’t fill anyone with confidence. And they went with youth and cheap options with Koscielny and Squillaci last summer – two players who may struggle to be first choice anywhere else in the country. Wozjiech Schezny appears to have emerged as a prospect for the future, but needs an experienced hand to aid his development, and that is no excuse for putting gooners through the calamitous years of the Almunia-Fabianski show. Then there was Wenger’s Walcott project in which he looks to take a quick young forward and make him the next Henry. Arsenal fans will argue that there are plenty of top players in the team, but is it honestly a title-winning side. There are too many inconsistent performers in Arshavin, Rosicky, Diaby, Walcott, Eboue, Bendtner etc. whilst key players such as Vermaelen and van Persie look increasingly like the treatment room will be their home from home each year.

I think the Nasri situation highlights a big problem at the Emirates, and this summer will prove to be the biggest in Wenger’s Arsenal reign…

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s